Phanindra

180020037 - 180020037 RAJEEVDASS - Attempt1 - 2022-04-16 9_36 am/Q3 - Design Summary/Question text

@@ -1,4 +0,0 @@
-Design Summary (add text in the box below or upload a PDF)
-Explain how you approach this design problem.
-Include your assumptions, trade-offs, with any and all design choices you make.
-

180020037 - 180020037 RAJEEVDASS - Attempt1 - 2022-04-16 9_36 am/Q4 - System Block Diagram/Question text

@@ -1,3 +0,0 @@
-Upload the block diagram of the system you have designed as a single PDF.
-
-Hand drawn diagram is acceptable - just make sure it is neat and clearly labelled. Mark all interfaces. Make sure to include suitable power supply/supplies.

180020037 - 180020037 RAJEEVDASS - Attempt1 - 2022-04-16 9_36 am/Q5 - Power Supply Summary/Question text

@@ -1,3 +0,0 @@
-Power Supply Summary (add text in the box below or upload a PDF. Handwritten+scanned is acceptable as long as it is neat and legible.)
-
-* Explain your choice of your power supply.	* Explain how your power supply works. Include circuit diagrams, waveforms and graphs as needed.

180020040 - 180020040 PHANINDRA - Attempt1 - 2022-04-16 9_06 am/Q3 - Design Summary/Question text

@@ -1,4 +0,0 @@
-Design Summary (add text in the box below or upload a PDF)
-Explain how you approach this design problem.
-Include your assumptions, trade-offs, with any and all design choices you make.
-

180020040 - 180020040 PHANINDRA - Attempt1 - 2022-04-16 9_06 am/Q4 - System Block Diagram/Question text

@@ -1,3 +0,0 @@
-Upload the block diagram of the system you have designed as a single PDF.
-
-Hand drawn diagram is acceptable - just make sure it is neat and clearly labelled. Mark all interfaces. Make sure to include suitable power supply/supplies.

180020040 - 180020040 PHANINDRA - Attempt1 - 2022-04-16 9_06 am/Q5 - Power Supply Summary/Question text

@@ -1,3 +0,0 @@
-Power Supply Summary (add text in the box below or upload a PDF. Handwritten+scanned is acceptable as long as it is neat and legible.)
-
-* Explain your choice of your power supply.	* Explain how your power supply works. Include circuit diagrams, waveforms and graphs as needed.

180020040 - 180020040 PHANINDRA - Attempt1 - 2022-04-16 9_06 am/Q6 - Industrial Design Summary/Question text

@@ -1,5 +0,0 @@
-Industrial Design Summary (add text in the box below or upload a PDF. Handwritten+scanned is acceptable as long as it is neat and legible.)
-
-	* Show (with labelled and dimensioned sketches) how your product will look (in the final form) as delivered to the end user. Include the enclosure, mounting etc as necessary.
-	* Explain in a few words what the enclosure is made of.
-

180020040 - 180020040 PHANINDRA - Attempt1 - 2022-04-16 9_06 am/Q7 - KiCAD Design/Question text

@@ -1,12 +0,0 @@
-Complete your entire design in Kicad, including:
-
-	* Circuit / schematic design:
-
-	* Make sure to assign the appropriate values / ratings for each component. When you select components make sure they exist on a commercial electronic platform (e.g. some are listed here: https://gitea.iitdh.ac.in/PEG/PEG-Wiki/wiki/PurchasingComponents)
-	* Assign appropriate footprints to each component
-	* Make sure to run the Electrical Rule Checker before moving to the layout.
-
-	* PCB Layout design
-
-When you are done, export the design as a SINGLE ZIP FILE (File > Archive) and then upload the zip file here. 
-

180020040 - 180020040 PHANINDRA - Attempt1 - 2022-04-16 9_06 am/Q8 - BOM/Question text

@@ -1,3 +0,0 @@
-Upload the Bill of materials (BOM) spreadsheet as a single XLS file. The spreadsheet should contain the following columns, at a minimum:
-
-* Reference designation	* Part number	* Value / Ratings

Shivam/Comments.txt

@@ -23,7 +23,12 @@ Design a system using a conductive water sensor (basically two metal probes that
 
 6.	KICAD Design
 	Schematic:
+	Looks good
 	
 	PCB:
+	No PCB Found. I've deducted some points for that but other responses are all ok.
+	
+7.	Pricing / BOM / Assembly
+	Why do you need 400V transistors?
+	Where are remaining components in the BOM + pricing? Connectors, pcb, etc...?
 
-7.	Pricing / Assembly

Swakath/Comments.txt

@@ -0,0 +1,39 @@
+Name: Swakath
+
+1.	Question text:
+Design a system using this Honeywell ammonia sensor (https://drive.google.com/file/d/164WvPD7GauvseOfH-K3v8iZ4YYmQFkq-/view?usp=sharing ) to detect when ammonia concentration in ambient atmosphere exceeds 100 ppm an alert an operator in a control room about 100m away. This device will be mounted in various sections of an industrial processing plant. The complete plant will need a fairly large number (~20) of sensors so unit costs needs to be kept under control. Also, once mounted it will be very difficult to remove/service/repair the sensing devices.
+
+
+2.	Design summary:
+	Overall approach is fine.
+	Good work finding th module that has a 4-20mA output directly
+
+
+3.	Block diagram
+	Why is there a common supply for both the sensor module and the receiver module?
+	They might be physically very far apart!
+	
+4.	Power supply design
+	The brick module may end up being underpowered for what you need.
+	Also, why design a rectifier filter and then use the module?
+	Power in a current-driven system is indeed tricky - you need to factor in the worst case 
+	voltage drop and times the current is power. 
+
+5.	Industrial Design:
+
+
+6.	KICAD Design
+	Schematic:
+	All good - good use of decoupling caps.
+	No Power on LED?
+	How exactly is the fault opamp working?
+	Also the OpAmp outputs are +/-12V. If you're connecting this to the uC you need to scale down to 5V or 3v3.
+
+	
+	PCB:
+	No Mounting holes?
+	Good use of pours
+	
+7.	Pricing / BOM / Assembly
+	The question asked for 2 prototypes - meaning two systems with about 20 sensor modules each.
+	But I guess this interpretation is fine too.