diff --git a/Shreya/Comments.txt b/Shreya/Comments.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c041dbe --- /dev/null +++ b/Shreya/Comments.txt @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +Name Shreya + +1. Question text: +Ammonia + +2. Design summary: + Design summary has only the basic circuit design.. I do not see the discussion of constraints, tradeoffs, etc. + Also, there are ~20 sensors and one control unit / control room. How are you integrating them all? + + +3. Block diagram + Overall aproach is ok - does not meet requirement as mentioned above. + + +4. Power supply design + Why is a 3A supply needed? + at that power why not go for a power brick? + Linear supply is too inefficient! + +5. Industrial Design: + Design was needed for multiple units! + Basic idea is ok. + +6. KICAD Design + Schematic: + Schematic does not load - you did not export the project properly + + PCB: + No PCB Found. + +7. Pricing / BOM / Assembly + No BOM submitted + Pricing is too optimistic. Sensor cost is not mentioned?/